Cakes
Birthday layers, small celebration cakes and sheet cakes sized for a classroom or a Sunday table. Tell us the flavor, the colors and the number of people, and we’ll build it to fit.
- Birthdays
- Celebrations
- Sheet cakes
Home bakery · Decatur and surrounding areas
Cakes, cookies and pies made for your people.
Sweet treats, made with heart, baked to order out of a home kitchen, in small batches, one order at a time. Tell us the occasion and the date, and we’ll take it from there.
- Baked to order
- Cakes, cookies, pies and more
- See pricing
What we bake
Three things, done properly.
A short list on purpose. Everything is mixed, baked and finished in a home kitchen the week you need it, never pulled from a freezer case.
Cookies
Sold by the dozen and baked the day they’re picked up. Good for bake sales, team snacks, teacher gifts, or a Tuesday that needs improving.
- By the dozen
- Bake sales
- Gift boxes
Pies
Fruit pies with a hand-crimped crust, plus cream pies when the weather calls for it. Holidays book up first, so it’s worth asking early if you need one for a specific date.
- Fruit pies
- Cream pies
- Holidays
How it works
Ordering takes about five minutes.
No account, no app, no checkout to fight with. It’s a conversation, then a box of something good.
Tell us the occasion
Send the form below with the date, roughly how many people you’re feeding, and anything you already have in mind. Call, text or email if you’d rather.
We confirm the details
You’ll get flavors, size and a firm price back before anything is baked. Nothing is locked in until you say yes.
Pick it up, or we bring it
We bake close to your date. Collection is always free. Delivery is $25 within 10 miles of Decatur, or $45 within 20, on orders of $50 or more. The pickup address is shared once your order is confirmed.
Recently out of the oven
A look at the work.
Little cakes, tall cakes, a good crimped crust and more cookies than anyone will admit to eating.
About the baker
Southern hospitality is always on the menu.
Welcome to Buttercup’s Baking Society, a home bakery in Decatur, Texas, specializing in cakes, cookies and pies made with love.
Inspired by family, playful gnomes, seasonal treasures, and a mischievous cat named Buttercup, every dessert is handcrafted to make life’s celebrations a little sweeter. Here, Southern hospitality is always on the menu.
The baker is Kim, and every order is made by her own hands.
- Baked to order, close to your date, never frozen ahead.
- You talk to the person doing the baking, start to finish.
- Local only, so the box travels minutes rather than days.
Kind words
What neighbors say.
Hands down the best lemon cookies ever. They are a top-tier treat with a perfect, melt-in-your-mouth texture and a bright, refreshing citrus flavor!
Kim makes the best desserts. Everything she makes is amazing. She just made me an apple pie for my birthday. Everyone thought it was the best apple pie they ever had 😊
Questions
Before you order.
How far ahead should I order?
Three days’ notice is enough for a typical order. Larger orders need longer, and weekends and holidays fill up first, so earlier is always safer. Get in touch as soon as you have a date and we’ll tell you straight away whether it’s doable.
What area do you serve?
Decatur and the surrounding areas. Collection is always free. Delivery is $25 within 10 miles of Decatur, or $45 within 20 miles, and is available on orders of $50 or more. If you’re further out, ask anyway, it’s often still workable.
What will my order cost?
Starting prices for the usual sizes are on the pricing page. Size, flavor and toppings move the number, and anything larger gets a written quote before we begin, so there are no surprises at pickup.
Can you handle allergies or dietary requests?
Everything is baked in a home kitchen that also handles wheat, eggs, dairy and nuts, so nothing can be promised free of traces of them. Every order goes out with an ingredient and allergen label. If you are avoiding something, say so before you order and Kim will tell you straight whether she can do it safely.
How do I pay?
You pay when you collect your order, not through this website. Everyday orders need no deposit. Orders of $100 or more take a 25% deposit to hold the date, and it is part of the price rather than an extra charge: on a $200 order that is $50 up front and $150 at collection. Full details are in the order terms.
Start your order
Tell us what you need baked.
Send an order request with the form and we’ll come back to you with flavors, size and a price. Email works just as well, whichever is easiest.
Call or text
(940) 278-7667
Email
[email protected]
Ordering hours
Always open
Send an order request whenever it suits you.
Service area
Decatur and surrounding areas
Send an order request
Fill this in and we’ll come back to you with flavors, size and a price.
